Best Litter Boxes
The litter box is the one piece of cat equipment your cat uses every day, so it is worth choosing carefully. A box that is too small, too enclosed, too hard to enter or too dirty is one of the most common reasons cats start avoiding the box. The good news is that most litter box problems come down to size, number, placement and cleaning, all of which you can fix without buying the most expensive box on the market.
This guide compares the main types, from simple open pans to automatic self cleaning boxes, and explains how to match the box to your cat’s size, age and habits. Check current retailer listings before you buy, since models, sizes and included accessories change often.
How Many Boxes, and How Big
The widely repeated guideline is one box per cat, plus one extra. One cat needs two boxes, two cats need three, and so on. The extra box matters because it gives each cat a choice and reduces queues and guarding, especially in multi cat homes. Spread the boxes around the house rather than lining them up in one room, since boxes side by side often count as one toilet spot in a cat’s mind.
Size matters more than style. A commonly cited rule is a box at least one and a half times your cat’s length from nose to tail base, with room to turn around fully, dig and squat without touching the sides. If your cat’s tail touches the wall, or litter and urine regularly end up over the rim, the box is too small. Large breeds and large cats need genuinely large boxes, not standard boxes with a large label.
Place boxes in quiet, accessible spots with an escape route, away from food and water bowls and away from noisy appliances. Cats avoid boxes they feel trapped in, and they avoid boxes next to a washing machine that may start mid visit. For a home with stairs, put at least one box on each floor your cat uses, and make sure a kitten or a senior cat does not have to travel far to reach one.
Open Top Boxes
Open top boxes are simple pans with no cover. They are cheap, easy to scoop, easy to clean and easy for a cat to enter from any side. They also give a cat a clear view of its surroundings, which nervous cats often prefer, and they ventilate better than covered boxes, so odour does not build up inside.
The downside is scatter. Digging cats kick litter out, and high spraying cats can miss the rim. High sided open boxes solve much of this. The IRIS Open Top Cat Litter Box with Shield and Scoop is a widely sold example, with tall sides and a removable rim. The Frisco High Sided Cat Litter Box is another common budget option, with a low entry cut into high walls. The Petmate Basic Cat Litter Pan with High Sides follows the same idea.
Open boxes suit most cats as a starting point, especially kittens, seniors and cats that have refused a covered box before. If scatter is the main complaint, add a litter mat outside the box and try a high sided pan before switching to a covered design your cat may dislike.
Covered and Hooded Boxes
Covered boxes have a hood over the pan, sometimes with a swinging door and a carbon filter in the top. They contain scatter and spray, hide the contents from view, and can help with odour in a small flat. The Catit Jumbo Hooded Cat Litter Box is a widely sold large covered option, with a hood that lifts for scooping. The Petphabet Covered Litter Box is another commonly listed spacious covered design.
Covered boxes are not right for every cat. Some cats dislike the enclosed feeling, especially if another cat waits outside the single entrance. Odour also builds up faster inside a hood, which can put a cat off even if the box looks clean to a human. If you use a covered box, scoop daily, clean the hood regularly, and consider removing the swinging door, since many cats prefer an open entrance to a flap they have to push.
Top entry boxes are a variation worth knowing about. The cat enters through a hole in the top, which cuts scatter and can deter dogs from investigating the litter. They suit agile adult cats, but they are a poor choice for kittens, seniors and cats with stiff joints, since jumping in and out is hard work. Watch for the same enclosed feeling problem as with other covered boxes.
High Sided and Stainless Steel Boxes
High sided boxes deserve their own mention because they solve the two most common open box complaints, scatter and spray, without adding a hood. Stainless steel versions have become popular for the same reason. Steel does not absorb odour the way scratched plastic does, and it wipes clean easily. The iPrimio Stainless Steel Cat Litter Box is a widely sold example of a large, high sided steel pan.
Steel pans cost more than plastic and can be heavier to carry to the bin, but owners who switch often report that lingering litter box smell drops noticeably. Plastic pans, by contrast, should be replaced when they become deeply scratched, since scratches trap odour even after washing. Whatever the material, a box with a low entry section helps kittens and older cats, while high walls on the other three sides contain digging.
Automatic and Self Cleaning Boxes
Automatic boxes scoop for you. Rake style boxes drag a rake through the litter after each use and drop clumps into a tray. Rotating globe boxes sift clumps into a sealed drawer. Washable systems flush waste away through a plumbing connection. Each design trades daily scooping for a machine that needs its own maintenance, consumables and floor space.
The Whisker Litter-Robot 4 is the best known rotating globe design. It suits up to four cats, uses clumping litter, and tracks visits and weight through an app. Whisker states that cats should weigh at least 3 lb for automatic mode, with lighter kittens using the unit only with the cycle switched off and run manually. Check the current manual before buying, since weight limits and litter guidance are exactly the details that change between models.
The PetSafe ScoopFree range uses crystal litter in a disposable tray that is replaced whole, which suits people who prefer a throwaway routine to emptying a drawer. The LitterMaid Self-Cleaning Litter Box is a lower cost rake style option. The CatGenie system washes and dries washable granules and needs a water and drain connection, so it suits a laundry room or bathroom with plumbing access rather than a bedroom corner.
Automatic boxes are not hands free. You still empty waste drawers or trays, top up litter, replace filters and liners, and wipe the unit down. They also cost more to run, since trays, liners and filters are ongoing purchases. Some cats refuse a moving, noisy box, so introduce any automatic box slowly, with the cycle switched off at first, and keep a normal box available until the cat chooses the new box willingly. Never force a frightened cat into an automatic box.
What to Look For When You Buy
Entry height and ease of access
Kittens, seniors and cats with mobility problems need a low entry. A high sided box with a low cut out entry gives you containment without a climb. Top entry and deep boxes with a high lip are the hardest to enter.
Cleaning effort
Ask how you will scoop, empty and wash the box in real life. A box with a hood that lifts fully is easier than one you have to dismantle. A heavy steel pan is easy to wipe but hard to lift when full. An automatic box saves scooping but adds drawer emptying, filter changes and occasional deep cleaning.
Litter compatibility
Automatic boxes are picky. Rotating globe boxes need hard clumping litter, ScoopFree boxes need crystal litter and trays, and washable systems need their own granules. Manual pans accept almost any litter, which makes it easier to switch litter if your cat rejects a type. Our best cat litter guide compares clumping, crystal, wood, paper and other litter types in detail.
Odour control that actually works
Odour control starts with scooping daily and a full litter change and wash on a regular schedule, not with a filter or a scented product. Carbon filters help in covered boxes but need replacing. Unscented litter suits most cats better than heavily scented litter, since a strong scent that pleases a human can put a cat off the box entirely.
Space and placement
Measure the spot before you buy, including clearance for a hood to lift or a globe to rotate. Automatic boxes are large appliances, not large pans. A box that blocks a doorway or forces a cat to squeeze past furniture will be used less, however good it looks in a product photo.
Comparison: Which Box Type Suits Which Home
| Box type | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Open top pan | Most cats, kittens, seniors, first box in a new home | Scatter, spray over a low rim |
| High sided open pan | Diggers, high sprayers, large cats | Entry height for small or stiff cats, floor space |
| Stainless steel pan | Odour sensitive homes, long term use | Weight when full, higher upfront cost |
| Covered or hooded box | Small flats, scatter control, privacy seeking cats | Trapped odour, single entrance, some cats refuse hoods |
| Top entry box | Agile adults, homes with dogs, scatter control | Hard for kittens and seniors, enclosed feeling |
| Automatic box | Busy homes, multi cat homes that hate scooping | Ongoing tray, liner and filter costs, weight limits, slow introduction needed |
Cleaning Routine That Keeps a Box in Use
Scoop at least once a day, and twice a day in a multi cat home. Top up litter so the depth stays around 3 to 4 inches, which lets a cat dig and cover properly. Wash the box with warm water and a mild, unscented soap whenever you do a full litter change, and rinse well so no soap smell remains. Avoid strong disinfectants and scented cleaners inside the box, since residue can put a cat off.
Keep a spare box while you wash the main one, so the cat is never left without a toilet. If you change litter type, mix the new litter with the old over several days rather than switching all at once, since many cats reject a sudden change in texture or scent under their paws.
When Box Avoidance Needs a Vet
A cat that suddenly avoids the box, strains, cries, passes very small amounts, goes much more or much less often than usual, or has blood in urine or stool needs prompt veterinary attention. These signs can point to urinary problems, constipation, pain or other health issues, and they are not solved by buying a new box. The same applies to a senior cat that starts missing the box, which can reflect mobility problems or a health change rather than naughtiness.
If the vet finds no health problem, work through the basics in order: enough boxes, large enough boxes, a quiet location, a litter type the cat accepts, and a cleaning routine the cat can rely on. Change one thing at a time, so you can tell what actually helped.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many litter boxes do I need?
The usual guideline is one per cat, plus one extra. Two boxes for one cat, three for two cats, and so on, spread around the home rather than grouped together.
Are automatic litter boxes safe for kittens?
It depends on the model and the kitten’s weight. For the Litter-Robot 4, Whisker states a 3 lb minimum for automatic mode, with lighter kittens using the unit only with the cycle off. Always check the manual for the exact model you buy, and keep a normal box available for a kitten.
Do covered boxes control odour better?
They hide odour from the room, but odour can build up inside the hood, which may put the cat off. Daily scooping and regular washing control odour more reliably than a hood alone.
How often should I replace a plastic litter box?
Replace a plastic pan when it becomes deeply scratched, stained or smelly after washing, since scratches trap odour. Stainless steel pans last longer, but still need regular washing.
A Short Note on Health Advice
This guide is general information for cat owners, not veterinary advice for an individual cat. Litter box changes can sometimes signal a health problem, so sudden avoidance, straining, blood, or a big change in toileting habits should be checked by a vet promptly rather than treated as a behaviour problem. If you are setting up for a new cat, our new cat owner starter kit covers litter boxes alongside the other first week essentials.
